Topic Harry Potter
Epoch
Shadowsong
Epoch
85 Human Paladin
5180
05/07/2011 10:59Posted by Lindoriel
They are enjoyable and somewhat well-written, however they lose their charm after reading them once(in my opinion). The first three/four books were also quite boring, in my opinion.

Not so. There is a toooooooon of foreshadowing in early books if you're into that kind of thing. Events that seemed insignificant at first reading become "wow, how did I miss that" moments later on.

For example, ---spoilers below---

the vanishing cabinet that Draco used to bring the death eaters into Hogwarts in Half-Blood Prince is first mentioned in passing in Chamber of Secrets, in Borgin and Burke's. Another (much more obvious) example is the locket horcrux, which was first introduced in Order of the Phoenix during the House of Black clean-out.
Ixie
Argent Dawn
Ixie
85 Gnome Mage
1570
Edited by Melaynna on 28/08/11 18:51 (BST)
They're /okay/ not really my type of thing, the books are acceptable but the movies have gone from nice childrens movies to a crappy twilight copy in the sense the latest movies just seem to be about teen drama.

Do not want.
Benii
Blade's Edge
Benii
90 Orc Rogue
10390
Edited by Benii on 23/09/11 02:47 (BST)
The books managed to draw me in, unlike the films (nothing unexpected) so yes, wonderful books, enjoyed reading them however not entirely my kind of book
Píckles
Burning Steppes
Píckles
90 Blood Elf Rogue
9415
I've grown up with them, i remember getting the first 4 just after the goblet of fire was released? back into 2000, so I would have been like 9 at the time
Turalise
Bronze Dragonflight
Turalise
90 Night Elf Warrior
10285
I 've read them all, but I couldn't read them now that I am older simply because the whole school setting is behind me.
Zazkya
Nagrand
Zazkya
85 Gnome Mage
1740
22/01/2012 02:06Posted by Turalyos
I 've read them all, but I couldn't read them now that I am older simply because the whole school setting is behind me.


You must be kidding.

Next thing you tell us you've never watched a James Bond movie because you aren't a secret agent.


Azabel
Sporeggar
Azabel
85 Draenei Death Knight
9815
I Love Harry potter... got the whole collection.
Started reading them so long ago and when they released the last book I couldn't believe that I would never ned to wait for "the new book to come out".

I'm reading right now Vampire Diaries and the Diaries too... and after that I will re-read HArry Potter... remembering my school times when I was awake till 5am to get up at 7 xD

Ps Im actually a "book eater" I love to read
Dysnomia
Azjol-Nerub
Dysnomia
85 Tauren Priest
4715
Anyone remember what Stuart Lee had to say on the matter?
Manalishi
Sunstrider
Manalishi
85 Blood Elf Mage
4005
22/01/2012 04:31Posted by Zazkya
I 've read them all, but I couldn't read them now that I am older simply because the whole school setting is behind me.


You must be kidding.

Next thing you tell us you've never watched a James Bond movie because you aren't a secret agent.

I don't know if I ever told you, but...

The whole setting of the HP universe is too childish for me, since the main character isn't 40 years old.

Also, whenever someone recommends the Godfather to me, I just go "nah, that Michael guy is just some inexperienced kid. And cops vs robbers is a kiddy game".
And of course, the Good, the Bad and the Ugly is just childish to me, since westerns are childish!
Poogles
Thunderhorn
Poogles
87 Gnome Rogue
1740
i LOVE the harry potter books. i'm so tired of people saying it sucks because they watched the movies and NOT read the books
Vakaran
Argent Dawn
Vakaran
85 Human Mage
3875
Harry Potter books were always great for me, giving a great way to curl up with a book and open up to an amazing would of magic and a world bigger than yourself. The writing is never to hard or easy to read, and there's the movies too.
Meerkat
Twisting Nether
Meerkat
85 Tauren Druid
7310
I first watched the movies and thought it mostly as a mediocre story.

But then I decided to purchase the books and holy hell are they amazing! :)

Although I really don't like the newest books THAT much.. Hell, I guess it's only 'cause of the fact that I hate to follow the story knowing that this beautiful tale will soon come to an end.
Arcbolt
Grim Batol
Arcbolt
85 Orc Hunter
7405
Edited by Arcbolt on 09/07/12 18:29 (BST)
I feel so lucky to have grown up with these books, as do so many others. JK Rowling inspired a whole generation of young readers/writers. When I have children of my own, they will grow up with these timeless stories too.
Pedqchovek
Neptulon
Pedqchovek
85 Gnome Mage
5875
Get that crud away from me.
Gankdálf
Draenor
Gankdálf
44 Undead Mage
4380
I read the first one when I was younger and I liked it but I never bothered getting the others.
The girl I like is crazy about them though :)

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Click here to view the Forums Code of Conduct.

Report Post # written by
Reason
Explain (256 characters max)

Reported!

[Close]