Topic Should Rogues beat Mages in duels?
Supêrstár
Grim Batol
Supêrstár
85 Undead Mage
0
Equally skilled.

I know they got semi-equal chances, but with this I ask: Is the duel favoring the Mage, or the Rogue?

I want your opinion!
Wonderberry
Crushridge
Wonderberry
85 Undead Warlock
3465
Edited by Wonderberry on 02/11/11 01:46 (GMT)
A sub rogue in 4.3 will cause havoc to a frost mage with the damage buffs to sub. On equal terms gear and skill, I would expect the Rogue to win even now.
Induktio
Ravencrest
Induktio
90 Human Rogue
5350
I would like to think that rogue vs mage 1on1 is pretty balanced
Triarii
Turalyon
Triarii
85 Blood Elf Mage
10115
Edited by Triarii on 02/11/11 07:56 (GMT)
inb4 random war n00b gonna complain about both classes.
Tayen
Darkmoon Faire
Tayen
85 Gnome Mage
7530
It's pretty equal, both can win. If the mage cold snaps I'd say it's a bit in their favour but the rogue certainly has a chance.
Narniä
Defias Brotherhood
Narniä
85 Worgen Mage
0
Shattered Barrier, Reacitve Barrier

without those talents its not easy to win with rogue.
Varlon
Shattered Halls
Varlon
85 Undead Mage
1960
Who in his right mind puts points into either?
Varlon
Shattered Halls
Varlon
85 Undead Mage
1960
In a perfect world the one who plays better should win. Sadly we are far from being in a perfect world.
Narniä
Defias Brotherhood
Narniä
85 Worgen Mage
0
02/11/2011 12:20Posted by Nelfomaniac
I can beat a frost mage blows all my cd's but can easily do it with right tactics


hmm i think frost mage can win rogue. I saw when mage defeated a rogue in duel. Rating of rogue 2,2k so he knew how to play right.


02/11/2011 12:51Posted by Varlon
In a perfect world the one who plays better should win. Sadly we are far from being in a perfect world


its not an answer. Everybody knows it. He means about class possibilities if both are smart (players).
Dutícyaa
Ravencrest
Dutícyaa
85 Blood Elf Mage
13700
02/11/2011 12:51Posted by Varlon
In a perfect world the one who plays better should win. Sadly we are far from being in a perfect world.


appearantly in a perfect world there is one class, no gearing and a set of preset skills and/or abilities
Seraphine
Eonar
Seraphine
80 Draenei Shaman
2720
Edited by Seraphine on 02/11/11 19:02 (GMT)
Mages totally own rogues im sorry. It's 1v1, it doesn't matter I'd like to add. But in my experience only the very best rogues have a chance against the decent mages. Blink step, IB if he cloaks when close to u, always keep your barriers up on and put them up on cd. He'll save trinket for deep most likely, assume that it will be trinketed. This lets you sheep when you want. Make sure to blizzard if he sits in smoke so he can't restealth. Kite them out of step range and learn to time when they'll be coming into range so you can be ready to blink before he can poison you. Soon as u can deep him when trinkets been used, pop your dmg trinket and mess him up. Reset with sheep + evocation if necessary. Easy really, you've got mirrors and ring and you don't even really need them.
Bódhi
Eonar
Bódhi
85 Human Mage
8345
02/11/2011 07:56Posted by Triarii
inb4 random war n00b gonna complain about both classes.

lol. yeah . warrs are full of !@#$ now. they are in a good place but cuz they were so op at end of wrath/start of cata they are crying like hell.
a good sub rogue is a pain. for any spec mage.
Narniä
Defias Brotherhood
Narniä
85 Worgen Mage
0
02/11/2011 19:01Posted by Seraphine
This lets you sheep when you want


hmm, u sheep rogue in duel ?
Seraphine
Eonar
Seraphine
80 Draenei Shaman
2720
Edited by Seraphine on 03/11/11 14:57 (GMT)
Yes it's an excellent way of controlling a rogue and making him blow his cooldowns before you actually kill him. Just casting it will force him to vanish / smoke or cloak. If you hit sheep straight after you blink step he's unlikely to get into gougeing range (watch for mind numbing), at least without good use of sprint. He has no way to escape if he's used trinket on deep and 8 seconds is enough time to get range and wait out poisons. It's simply a cooldown game where you must force the rogue to blow x2 vanish, x2 smoke and x2 cloak before you can kite him around in circles for an easy win.
Histamine
Chromaggus
Histamine
90 Blood Elf Mage
9370
(Fire) mage > rogue atm
After the 4.3 huge fire buff, it will stay that way.
Naeya
Defias Brotherhood
Naeya
83 Night Elf Warrior
3595
02/11/2011 07:56Posted by Triarii
inb4 random war n00b gonna complain about both classes.

*Shakes raging fist and shouts obscenities*

03/11/2011 02:23Posted by Jonirenicus
inb4 random war n00b gonna complain about both classes.

lol. yeah . warrs are full of !@#$ now. they are in a good place but cuz they were so op at end of wrath/start of cata they are crying like hell.

Your style of writing, grammar and punctuation tell me you are an extremely intelligent person capable of in-depth thoughts and reasoning whose opinion should be valued very highly.
Haydenwk
Stormscale
Haydenwk
85 Undead Mage
10745
Both equal players & this season? A mage should win without a huge problem, i'm beating people my experience & more without a huge problem, never seem to lose against rogues anyways, :x
Capow
Kazzak
Capow
85 Human Rogue
3715
In an arena environment with potential LoS objects, I believe a rogue would actually have a pretty decent chance. With no LoS, mage should win it fairly easily.
Sycex
Darkspear
Sycex
85 Night Elf Rogue
3440
yeah with los rogues just wait out cooldowns, in a duel mage should win everytime

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Click here to view the Forums Code of Conduct.

Report Post # written by
Reason
Explain (256 characters max)

Reported!

[Close]