Topic Gurthalak, voice of the deeps.
Terran
Vek'nilash
Terran
6 Tauren Druid
0
Edited by Terran on 13/01/12 13:03 (GMT)
13/01/2012 09:00Posted by Altera
"A ret paladin killed my parents." - GC



So the ret is this case wasnt hitcapped and missed his real target ;-)
Anyway , after more testing its pretty clear they overnerfed us by a large margin .
They really need to revisit this one . Seems like 1 less ret in the panda expansion .
Kelth
Scarshield Legion
Kelth
85 Undead Warrior
2045
Edited by Kelth on 14/01/12 04:11 (GMT)
13/01/2012 07:34Posted by Drfantastic
Each attempt I did a pretty consistent 27k DPS and damage from tentacles accounted for 3-4% of that each time (pretty poor compared to other classes, I know it's random but this was over 5 or 6 fairly long static fights)


I did some LFR's today and I looked at the damage from tentacles from various classes.
I didn't see a Fury Warrior, but Frost DK2H, Unholy, and Arms all had 3-4% dmg done from tentacles
Kvaern
Sunstrider
Kvaern
85 Blood Elf Paladin
8750
14/01/2012 04:08Posted by Kelth
Each attempt I did a pretty consistent 27k DPS and damage from tentacles accounted for 3-4% of that each time (pretty poor compared to other classes, I know it's random but this was over 5 or 6 fairly long static fights)


I did some LFR's today and I looked at the damage from tentacles from various classes.
I didn't see a Fury Warrior, but Frost DK2H, Unholy, and Arms all had 3-4% dmg done from tentacles


Excluding the 2H frost (Who plays that anyway???) then either those chars were insanely well geared, or they had bad RNG, or you looked at overall data which can be skewed by people not knowing where to stand to make it proc properly on Ultraxion and MoDW.

My arms warrior is getting 6%-15% from gurt and my pala about half that but granted the warrior is not as well geared as the pala so the real difference isn't that large.

The bottom line is that there certainly is a very noticeable difference in procrate between the 2 specs which is shown by the sim figures/parses as well.

Anyway I'm not too worried about the SoT bug fix/nerf in itself, but I think the statement that Ret was doing too much damage when the spec had 2 parses in Ultraxion top 100 (the best being something like #86) at the time is a slap in the face (appropriate cliche in this case).
We were basically told that ret isn't allowed to be in the upper half of DPS specs and that is unacceptable.
Bodom
Moonglade
Bodom
90 Orc Death Knight
10285
14/01/2012 10:58Posted by Kvaern
Excluding the 2H frost (Who plays that anyway???)


A death knight with Gurthalak.
Wahnsin
Twisting Nether
Wahnsin
85 Undead Mage
1800
Edited by Wahnsin on 14/01/12 16:34 (GMT)

My arms warrior is getting 6%-15% from gurt and my pala about half that but granted the warrior is not as well geared as the pala so the real difference isn't that large.


Perhaps your Warrior's Mastery is making is proc better. I know that the Unholy Dk Mastery becomes better then Crit with Gurthalak .
Bodom
Moonglade
Bodom
90 Orc Death Knight
10285

My arms warrior is getting 6%-15% from gurt and my pala about half that but granted the warrior is not as well geared as the pala so the real difference isn't that large.


Perhaps your Warrior's Mastery is making is proc better. I know that the Unholy Dk Mastery becomes better then Crit with Gurthalak .


Crit has never been any good to death knights though.
Wahnsin
Twisting Nether
Wahnsin
85 Undead Mage
1800
14/01/2012 23:27Posted by Bodom
Crit has never been any good to death knights though.


Standard Weights
Strength 3.65
Hit (to cap) 3.00
Haste 1.89
Crit 1.85
Mastery 1.55

Expertise (to cap) 0.99
AP 0.85

Adjusted Weights for 4pc Tier and Gurthalak, Voice of the Deeps
Strength 3.65
Hit (to cap) 3.90
Haste 2.50
Crit 2.11
Mastery 2.19

Expertise (to cap) 1.43
AP 0.85

Do you want me to tell you more about your class or will you be okay from here.
Tethali
Silvermoon
Tethali
90 Night Elf Death Knight
2750
Has anyone ever thought that Blizz just don't like Pala's? I made mines back when they were arguably the best dps for that time, then people started complaining and they just got worse and worse thats why I made a DK, and personally when I get Gurthalak on my DK well....= WIN!
Prowz
Ragnaros
Prowz
90 Gnome Rogue
11080
Isn't there an internal cd on this thing? Seems retarded that there wouldn't be one.
Raskolnik
Emerald Dream
Raskolnik
85 Worgen Death Knight
6440
14/01/2012 11:43Posted by Bodom
Excluding the 2H frost (Who plays that anyway???)


A death knight with Gurthalak.


indeed ... am seeing on average about 13% of total is coming from tentincles ... had three up last night, was very woo !!!
Xanbajin
Twisting Nether
Xanbajin
90 Troll Warrior
14370
dear fellow dps's with 2handers i can confirm the 390 item lvl from lfr is even better then hc fl and raggy hc it's bis over 397weaps bis before hc ds and normal ds version of the weap iff ya are a fury dps ..but seen how much better the numbers are it will be bis for dk and pala to.

don't mind the secondary stats i thought it was crap to at first but when i did reserach its even better, the tentacle does big dps for you proc's verry often, no need for those secondary stats.

Squarefaced
Tarren Mill
Squarefaced
90 Blood Elf Paladin
8985
HA.

18/01/2012 22:01Posted by Xanbajin
no need for those secondary stats.


Got 1% of my damage on zonozz hc yesterday done by tentacle sword, would much rather take the 410 axe over the tentacles on a fight like Spine where you can't rely on the procs.. I HAVE NEVER SEEN THIS FABLED >10%!
Bodom
Moonglade
Bodom
90 Orc Death Knight
10285
Edited by Bodom on 22/01/12 01:58 (GMT)
15/01/2012 01:46Posted by Wahnsin
Do you want me to tell you more about your class or will you be okay from here.


Mastery was better than crit the last time I was fooling around as unholy :<
Cremation
Saurfang
Cremation
85 Worgen Death Knight
7575
22/01/2012 01:52Posted by Bodom
Do you want me to tell you more about your class or will you be okay from here.


Mastery was better than crit the last time I was fooling around as unholy :<


They fixed pet scaling with our stats now so crit became higher than mastery

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Click here to view the Forums Code of Conduct.

Report Post # written by
Reason
Explain (256 characters max)

Reported!

[Close]