Topic Rate the healer above, part 3
Treeroy
Aerie Peak
Treeroy
85 Tauren Druid
6825
Edited by Treeroy on 26/01/12 19:54 (UTC)
Since part 2 was full, let's start another one.

Please no things like "get better gear", that doesn't help anyone. :)
Renae
Frostwhisper
Renae
85 Blood Elf Paladin
8630
@Treeroy: Reforge your weapon/OH to haste to reach the 2005 cap.

Other than that, 7/10
Starstruck
Wildhammer
Starstruck
85 Night Elf Druid
3605
Edited by Starstruck on 27/01/12 10:53 (UTC)
@Treeroy
You got an empty Major Glyph, would use Glyph of Healing Touch.
And why you didnt skill Natures Grace? Nice in combination with Healing Touch for a quick live saver.


@Renae

The only thing you could replace with Vp, is the Neck but Ill guess you`ll loose out too much on Haste.
Also I see that youre going for every Set Bonus even when its only +10 like on the Hands, Int with Spr + Set Bonus is 35Ing with 25Sp, wouldnt 50Int be better?
Since I dont know that much about Pala heals and it looks pretty gooed I`d say 9/10.



Myself is an alt and I need to farm some money to replace some more Gems with Inferno Rubys^^
Renae
Frostwhisper
Renae
85 Blood Elf Paladin
8630
Edited by Renae on 04/02/12 13:29 (UTC)
27/01/2012 10:51Posted by Starstruck
The only thing you could replace with Vp, is the Neck but Ill guess you`ll loose out too much on Haste.


Kinda, aye. Mainly though, I'd lose around 50 int or so. I'm waiting for Morchok to drop the 410 necklace though. :p

27/01/2012 10:51Posted by Starstruck
Also I see that youre going for every Set Bonus even when its only +10 like on the Hands, Int with Spr + Set Bonus is 35Ing with 25Sp, wouldnt 50Int be better?


Waiting for the gloves from Deathwing to drop before I use a 50-int gem (well, two). I'm only using a 25int/25spirit gem in the tier at the moment because 1) it's cheap, 2) I lose out on 5 int from using an epic int/spi gem, and gain 25 spirit, opposed to using a 40int gem.

As for on the ring, at the time it was to activate my meta. ^_^

RATE STARSTRUCK
Ashalia
Kilrogg
Ashalia
85 Draenei Priest
10330
@Starstruck

I despise spirit trinkets, reforged or not.
Gemming pure mastery, not a big fan of that either but thats more a choice then anything else. (Would prefer 20/20 or 25/25 if you got the gold, though you already said you were going to fix this)
Wasted prismatic socket on belt with a 20/20 gem.
Sub-optimal enchant on chest, bracers and gloves.
Gear wise you are also ready for the +3% crit gem rather then +2% mana.
Reforging mastery into... something then back to mastery oO;;
Might be time to get rid of furor (But that is again a choice).
Herbalism is rather sub-par as far as professions go. I mean the haste buff? Please -.-;;

6.5/10
Kokolin
Bronze Dragonflight
Kokolin
85 Human Priest
5925
I'd give you 10/10 straight away.

You definatley put a lot of effort to meet the demands.
Nice progress too. :)
Sigrid
Alonsus
Sigrid
85 Draenei Priest
9860
@ Kokolin 8/10

I really wouldnt gem for pure mastery. And I would ignore the socket bonus in that ring completely. Your reforging could use some optimizing aswell.

I'm guessing using renew as main filler? You can safely drop Body and Soul for DS unless you are progressing on Hagara hc. A pretty good alternative is Blessed Resilience which should have a decent uptime.

Your chest needs +20 stats instead of that horrid spi enchant.
Synx
Al'Akir
Synx
85 Blood Elf Paladin
6840
10/10

I wonder why you've not specced for Atonement :o
Ravenhair
Magtheridon
Ravenhair
85 Night Elf Druid
7985
@ Synx

10/10

Don't see anything wrong with your gear, gems, enchs and reforging plus everything else seems to be in place.
Nyxta
Wildhammer
Nyxta
85 Night Elf Druid
4570
10/10 you appear to have spent a long time raiding etc, however there is only one slight error and it's that you have a ring with hit rating.

But you still are worthy of 10 and I'm not really in a position to judge, since I don't have a clue how to use druids, haha.
Wenlei
Hellscream
Wenlei
85 Night Elf Priest
2960
@Nyxta: Missing several enchants, an unused prismatic gem socket, several non-optimal gems (for example, there is no reason why you would put a purified demonseye in a red socket - except if they are way too expensive on your AH - this by the way is the reason I have not put epic gems everywhere :/). If you cant afford the best enchants, try getting at least the second best, which are usually much less expensive.

Regarding spec, I would have urged you to pick up the Nature's Cure talent in earlier patches, in particular if focusing on 5-mans. Nowadays, well ... probably you are not going into normal mode and in LFR dispells are not *that* important. If you do try to PuG normal mode at some point though ... people might start yelling at you for not dispelling Disrupting Shadows on Zonozz.

Still, more effort than some other examples I have seen: 6.5/10
Spungi
Silvermoon
Spungi
85 Human Paladin
3935
Don't know anything about priests if I'm to be honest :P But in my eyes, it looks like you're doing it right (going for mastery)
And gear looks good, so I'll probably go with a 9/10 :)
Sufenta
Shattered Hand
Sufenta
85 Human Priest
4970
Well the one thing I know about paladins are you need loads of haste so thats good. Got a lot of that. Hopefully You've reached some sort of cap :)

Missing engineering tinkers?

Also nice with the 4-set for the little extra boost to the Holy radiance! :) works out great in DS! :D

9/10
Kidja
Sylvanas
Kidja
85 Blood Elf Paladin
12455
All good , can`t see anything wrong with spec/reforge and glyphs.
I personally love priests , love to work with them in our 10m raids.

10/10
Wenlei
Hellscream
Wenlei
85 Night Elf Priest
2960
@Kidja: More or less same gear level and progress as me - must be good 10/10 :D

(Just fill in that minor glyph slot with something useless so you pass the audit ;))
Senkotron
Auchindoun
Senkotron
85 Human Priest
5725
I see that you, guys, go for less spirit than I have, but I'm not feeling OK with my mana regen. And to add that I am not lucky at all with the trinkets :( I kind of like my haste level, but would love to hear your advices
PS: Maybe it's just some misjudgement with the mana thing
Nytramix
Ravenholdt
Nytramix
85 Human Priest
7215
7/10

If you have mana problems u can try heartsong on your weapon, it may look cheap !@# but its really good at progression and if you have mana problems.
Also your trinkets are not the best choice, dont always go for the highest item level. i.e, Core or Ripeness is better then your 1st slot trinket, dont always look at the item level.
also try to get intellect stat on your trinkets since it increases your mana pool so you won't be oom that quick.

P.S dont tell me to use PT i know what im doing ;)
Sigrid
Alonsus
Sigrid
85 Draenei Priest
9860
Nytramix 8/10

Get some epic gems.

You can safely replace lavawalker to +50 haste/mastery enchant, DS fights are either very very static or you have 25% speedboost (yor, zonozz).

If you are having regen problems pick up veiled shadows which would allow you to use power torrent on MH aswell.
Bahram
Bronze Dragonflight
Bahram
85 Draenei Shaman
1480
Edited by Bahram on 02/02/12 14:26 (UTC)
Nytramix 8/10

Get some epic gems.

You can safely replace lavawalker to +50 haste/mastery enchant, DS fights are either very very static or you have 25% speedboost (yor, zonozz).

If you are having regen problems pick up veiled shadows which would allow you to use power torrent on MH aswell.


Your gear and gems made me cream a little, the reforges are perfect and the ench are spot on....10/10
Wenlei
Hellscream
Wenlei
85 Night Elf Priest
2960
Edited by Wenlei on 02/02/12 17:18 (UTC)
@Bahram: Too bad you are not on Hellscream, we could use a resto shaman. ;)

You seem to be doing it right (assuming that you have someone else in your raid composition that takes care of the dispels), but that little extra effort missing for the very top mark, such as leveling your professions to max - and maybe choosing something different from herbing. 9.5/10

I would appreciate if the next person actually rated me (Senkotron, I am looking at you :P).

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Click here to view the Forums Code of Conduct.

Report Post # written by
Reason
Explain (256 characters max)

Reported!

[Close]