Come to my server, experience the joys of AH scrolls.
I hate the button, it has made me miserable too many times.
Why are you calling my arguments stupid? If it bothers me, it bothers me, no matter how stupid or infantile they may sound to you.
You know this to be a fact?
I wish I could, I see lots of opportunities to make gold. It's a lower amount of sales, but more profit per scroll compared to my server, and I sold scrolls for 2.5 million in Cataclysm.
Why do you hate the button? It brings more materials to the auction house, it makes something take no time that previously took 1 minute per dungeon run, and it increases the profit potential for an enchanter. Not a dungeon disenchanter (because materials will lower in value, and you'll get the same amount of mats), but an enchanter.
I'm not calling your arguments stupid, I'm calling them bad. I call them bad because they're not very effective if your intention was to get it changed. Of course no arguments so far have been effective when it comes to getting DE changed, but when it comes to trying to get other profession things changed, "I make less money" have pretty much not worked ever. It's the wrong angle of attack when it comes to making Blizzard change something.
I don't know it to be a fact, but I can say with a high probability that it won't be changed by remembering the amount of complaining that was brewed before it was implemented, and that nothing was done. And when it comes to a lot of other changes Blizzard have done, they very rarely go back on them. Especially not for something as small as disenchanting, for as something as small as professions. It's sad, but realistic. So instead of me hoping for the game to change into something I want it to be, and having a worse gaming experience because it hasn't been changed yet, I make the best of what it actually is.
Another reason why it most likely won't change, is that there aren't enough people against it. There are so many enchanters now that like it, and are having a better experience as an enchanter because of it, that you don't get hundreds of people every day making threads against it. One of the few proposed patch changes I remember them completely removing because of public outcry, was when the tailoring BoP crafts in TBC were going to be nerfed from Tier5 to around Tier 4.5. Tailors went crazy and filled two threads to the limit in a few days (1000 replies on EU forums alone), and the nerf was pulled. You never had that for DE, and you won't get that anymore, because there are fewer people strongly against it, and there are more people for it that balance the opinions.