Dethroned during vacation.

85 Dwarf Warrior
5670
Hello,

I am founder of the guild <Prime> together with 7 of my in real life friends. About 5 weeks ago 12th of January i left my home country of Sweden for Thailand. During my time there I would not be able to play or in any other way communicate. So 3rd of January I believe my account was canceled(frozen), I would not activate it till I came back. So today I reactivated my account and got myself a bit of a chock.

I first noticed that some random person which I didn't know had the title as Guild Master. After a short conversation with the current GM someone stole the title as Guild Master and took everything from the bank and sold the guild for 30k gold.

Talking to a Game Master didn't give me anything since they weren't able to get the title back or making a new guild with same specs. I was told to go here and write what I'm thinking.

So I took my time to find this forum and I hope for goodness sake there is something you can do about my issue. Unaware of the change in policies and upcoming patches we left home. Me and my friends are all very upset for what has happened during the time we were gone and hope there is something you can do about this.

1 Year of Paying for World of Warcraft is allot of money for a student. 1 Year of spending time is allot of hours of work put into something that would be stolen by someone making un-honest profit.

The current "Guild Master" might consider to sell the guild to me for 30k gold. But I don't have either time or energy to put into getting that kind of money in wow. And I surely don't want it because of principles.


As I posted in another forum. If Blizzard cant do anything about this, I want it changed. That system is just plain stupidity. Worked well before, why change.
Reply Quote
21 Human Paladin
0
Don't listen to Lazio. His comments are unacceptable
Reply Quote
18 Troll Druid
70
Owned.

Don't abandon your guild for 30 days.
Reply Quote
88 Tauren Priest
5305
20/02/2012 21:29Posted by Bruceelee
Don't listen to Lazio. His comments are unacceptable

I'd say a bit blunt, but hey, hardly worth reporting him over (i'm guessing it was you).

@Slaxx - so where were your friends (who you set the guild up with) while you were on holiday/busy being dethroned?


*Edit - you wont get much sympathy round here mate.
Edited by Dysnomia on 21/02/2012 10:31 GMT
Reply Quote
85 Human Priest
11390
Why didn't you just add to one of the 50 threads already on this subject instead of making a new one? Your situation is not special, you abandoned your guild and the people in it for an extended period of time, what did you think would happen?

20/02/2012 21:02Posted by Slaxx
The current "Guild Master" might consider to sell the guild to me for 30k gold. But I don't have either time or energy to put into getting that kind of money in wow.


If you don't have either time or energy to grind 30k in wow then I would suggest you may want to rethink your aspiration to become a guild leader.
Reply Quote
85 Night Elf Priest
5720
Hi Slaxx,

1. Where did your 7 real life friends go?

2. This policy is not new, they just made it more obvious to people left stranded by their Guild Leader.

In my personal opinion I think anyone who wants to be a Guild Leader with a guild encompassing people who are not RL friends should be aware of ALL changes to rules. Did you want Blizzard to help recruit and tidy the bank for you aswell?

Sorry Slaxx but your a victim of your own downfalls here dude
Reply Quote
85 Human Priest
11390
20/02/2012 22:10Posted by Dysnomia
*Edit - you wont get much sympathy round here mate.


I think we were nice to at least the first 12 people with this problem... !
Reply Quote
88 Tauren Priest
5305
21/02/2012 10:41Posted by Serenal
I think we were nice to at least the first 12 people with this problem... !

Liked.
And to our credit too, then ;o)

Yep, understanding and tollerance only goes so far...

I'm still trying to work out what Blucelee's 'chip on the shoulder' is for.
Edited by Dysnomia on 21/02/2012 10:50 GMT
Reply Quote
Community Manager
Thanks for your thoughts on this Slaxx. As always, we see your feedback and have taken note.

However, unfortunately, the system is rightly in place to protect people from long-standing inactive guild masters, giving higher-ranked characters in a guild a chance to take over after a full 30 days and resume guild leader activities. Had you promoted just one of your real-life friends to any rank higher than those players whom you did not know, this incident would not have occurred :-(

Hopefully people will become more aware of this mechanic over time.
Reply Quote
6 Dwarf Priest
0
However, unfortunately, the system is rightly in place to protect people from long-standing inactive guild masters, giving higher-ranked characters in a guild a chance to take over after a full 30 days and resume guild leader activities. :-(


I would call a person with a FROZEN account who has not played WoW for 90 days or more "longterm", not an active subscriber who just wanted to go on a holiday.


Had you promoted just one of your real-life friends to any rank higher than those players whom you did not know, this incident would not have occurred


Iluvcritters, the above "blue" quote is exactly what people on this mb have been telling you for about 4 months now.
You actually do not even read posts to which you reply, do you?
You have now posted the exact same wall of text 9 or more times without ever replying to people that take the time and effort to reply to you.
Does the word Netiquette mean anything to you?
Reply Quote
88 Tauren Priest
5305
21/02/2012 15:03Posted by Iluvcritters
See my post in the other thread about making it that a dethrone requires 4 signatures from approving players in the guild

Wow, one i agree with you on, good-job ILC. It would mean there would be more of a consensus when a guild leader was dethroned, but NOT that it wouldnt happen in the first place.

21/02/2012 15:03Posted by Iluvcritters
I've seen a rise of "Guild For Sale" posts on the forums... how many of these are guilds that got grabbed???
Or maybe the way things are now instead of just disbanding guilds when they merge players people are selling them as it leaves something that is quite valuable behind... You seem to see everything interms of "Guild for sale - OMG i bet thats been stolen from some poor, unfortunate, inoccent GM who just happened to be a bit AFK for too long."

Questions I wonder over:
1) if you dethrone a player and then it is found that they were dethroned on day 29 and not day 30, are you going to give a guild back then?
2) will you refund our guild website costs such a dethroned guild leader now has lost?
3) why is it so hard for you to do the same requirement of 4 signatures as with a guild creation?
4) are you removing this tool tip soon because it's an insult for every guild leader who followed it and then got punished: "Bring your friends to Azeroth, but don't forget to go outside Azeroth with them as well." (they did that and it lost them a guild)

1) are you making this up now, where has 29 days come from?

2) that is an auxiliary function, and also available free if you just look around.

3) because youve just come up with it, and it may take a while to implement...

4) do we have to paraphrase everything like smallprint in advert to not get sued by some idiot who didnt realise that coffee is hot, other liquids are wet and peanuts contain nuts!
ok, will apend "(but obviously not for longer than thirty days!)" to that tooltip.
Edited by Dysnomia on 21/02/2012 16:33 GMT
Reply Quote
100 Night Elf Hunter
19285
Thanks for your thoughts on this Slaxx. As always, we see your feedback and have taken note.

However, unfortunately, the system is rightly in place to protect people from long-standing inactive guild masters, giving higher-ranked characters in a guild a chance to take over after a full 30 days and resume guild leader activities. Had you promoted just one of your real-life friends to any rank higher than those players whom you did not know, this incident would not have occurred :-(

Hopefully people will become more aware of this mechanic over time.


And to be honest we can copy and paste this replay to every QQ moan on here about people loosing their guilds.
Reply Quote
88 Tauren Priest
5305
21/02/2012 16:59Posted by Spacemonk
And to be honest we can copy and paste this replay to every QQ moan on here about people loosing their guilds.

Dunno mate, I think I'd put it on the front of a guild charter with three or four checkboxes saying
"have you read it - []yes []no"
"are you sure - []yes []no"
"really sure - []yes []no"
"go on then you can have your guild, but you have read that you do need to take a little better care of it, and dont blame us when you loose it, just like your new Ipod that mummy just tutted and bought you another one the very next day."
Edited by Dysnomia on 21/02/2012 17:31 GMT
Reply Quote
100 Night Elf Druid
21765
While it is mostly pointless to answer any of Iluvcritters' posts since she just move on to a different thread without even taking anything anyone answers on board, I want to comment on one thing, again.

21/02/2012 15:03Posted by Iluvcritters
And I say again, if you think if the FIRST member of a guild should not stay away from a guild for 30 days or more, then what about the other up to 999 other members. They can go offline and stay offline for months or even years without you knowing where they have gone. They can go play six months of SWTOR without a care in the world. In a guild there are up to ONE THOUSAND players who make the guild work, so if a guild leader gets demoted after 30 days of being away, then add the automation in so guild members get kicked TOO when offline 30 days or more, and I assure you'll have 90% of the players being guildless tomorrow, and you'll have a riot on your hands from all of them for becoming guildless. Just because it is the creator of the guild, don't treat them like we're something not worth it.


It's up to the guild leader to set the rules for any guild. He can remove people after 30 days of inactivity, 20 days, 10 day, 5 days, 24 hours, whatever. The guild leader already has the tools to kick anyone or everyone from the guild at any given moment. Why should there need to be additional tools that do the same as the existing ones? As long as there is a leadership in the guild it's up to that leadership if and when to deguild members.

However if the guild leader stops playing there are no higher ranks to remove him, no leadership that can step in, since he alone is the highest rank, and thus this tool is needed. Get it? Like Dumpey says, it's an MMO, and a guild is a dynamic community of other players. You can't expect to press pause for weeks on end and return to see everything is the same as it was. Especially not if you have taken on a responsibility to lead your community and you aren't upholding your end of the deal. Becoming a guild leader is not like receiving a sovereign title/rank, where you get it and keep it for life. It's more like a job, if you don't do your job for an extended period of time you better well expect your position to be filled by someone else when you bother to return.

I think you should be so lucky your guildies aren't reading through the uninformed rubbish you post on these forums. Any respect you have would be lost.
Reply Quote
21 Human Paladin
0
21/02/2012 14:02Posted by Takralus
Hopefully people will become more aware of this mechanic over time.
Hopefully someone else will get more Aware that 1 month is WAY to short time period.

as Iluvcritters said :
21/02/2012 15:03Posted by Iluvcritters
I would call a person with a FROZEN account who has not played WoW for 90 days or more "longterm", not an active subscriber who just wanted to go on a holiday.
Reply Quote

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Forums Code of Conduct

Report Post # written by

Reason
Explain (256 characters max)

Reported!

[Close]