Common Problems
- I completed all criteria and didn't get Insane in the Membrane Achievement or Title
- I was Honored with Bloodsail Buccaneers before grinding Goblin rep, but didn't get Insane in the Membrane achievement after getting Exalted with all of the Goblin factions
- If I lose reputation with the Bloodsail Buccaneers while I'm working on Booty Bay, will I still be able to get the achievement?
Modern WoW
In Modern WoW, the Insane in the Membrane achievement is still available and can be completed. It is a single character achievement, so reputation gains on additional characters will not count towards the achievement.
While you do not have to have all the reputations simultaneously, there are community recommendations for the easiest way to complete this achievement for tracking reputations. Check Wowhead's Insane in the Membrane guide for more information.
Classic WoW
The Classic version of this achievement requires a character to reach a state where all the criteria in the achievement are true at the same time. This means characters will need to be exalted with all the goblin reputations at the same time as being honored with Bloodsail Buccaneers.
The WoW team has confirmed this is true to how the achievement originally worked when the achievement system first came out before it was later changed to function like how it currently does in Modern WoW.